Filed Under: Hollywood Whodunit?   »

This rock star claims to be many things - he says he's a devout Christian, a vegan, and a complete teetotaler - no alcohol, no drugs. But he does have a weakness for pretty woman. One of his former pretty women says he's a BIG FAKE. She claims that not only does he eat meat and NOT live by Christian values, but he's a hardcore pill-popper and a member of Narcotics Anonymous. His current girlfriend isn't complaining - she's a cokehead and compulsive liar herself.


Posted by Janet Charlton on July 22, 2008 9:14 PM
THIS IS WHAT YOU THINK

Ex-Lead singer from Korn or Scott Stapp

Posted by: Anonymous


Moby...
and he's not a rock star (you're using the term loosly), but anyway...

Posted by: ejmc


just google "rock star & Christian & vegan" (and not rockstar together ... google it separetly)... click on the second link titled: "EVU - Moby, the Vegan Star"

Posted by: ejmc


Nichole Richie's man! After all she's not a wife but a girlfriend. Same can be said for the brother and Paris.

Posted by: Anonymous


Yeah, Moby for sure. What an asswipe.

Posted by: Dana


Moby is gay (not that there's anything wrong with that)

Posted by: Anonymous


First name that popped in my head is Lenny "I'm celibate" Kravitz. He's a known vegetarian (although I'm not sure he is vegan), he proclaims his Christianity, he has dated some of the most beautiful women in the world.....he fits!

Posted by: Anonymous


Moby hasn't come out officially as gay. He's more the type to pretend to be gay so he can be seen as an "outsider". In other words, just for the shock value. Since it isn't so shocking anymore, you don't hear him talk about it much.

Posted by: Dana


Moby isn't really a rock star. More house, new wave, indie. Here are other good guesses: Bryan Adams (vegan abstains from alcohol) and Alice Cooper (abstains from alcohol, christian).....well??

Posted by: Anonymous


it has to be benji madden. he says he is a vegetarian and his current girlfriend is a compulsive liar and most likely a cokehead as well. two fakes- they belong together.

Posted by: Anonymous


The Madden brothers aren't Christian bible beaters and they don't abstain from alcohol. So that cancels them out.

Posted by: Anonymous


Lenny Kravitz is Jewish. The person in question seems to be really religious. Alice Cooper is a born again Christian and also claims he's completely abstained from alcohol. No idea whether he's a vegetarian.

Posted by: Anonymous


The Madden brothers are devout christians. They're both vegetarians and both claim they've completely abstained from alcohol and drugs. They've both dated beautiful women in the past. Not shocking that they're liars. The cokehead, lying girlfriend may be either Nicole or Paris. How fitting!

Posted by: Anonymous


Scott Stapp for sure

Posted by: Anonymous


HELLO? Anybody? Hasn't anyone seen the new PETA ad? Paul McCartney, I rest my case! This one was easy, Janet, challenge me.

Posted by: afashionist:a:'actually'youwouldliketo know


I'm going to concur about Madden, back in the late '90's hanging out on upper Haight, I'm POSITIVE I shared a J while waiting out the rain with those two twins. How many twins had one with those horrible tats on the FACE, I think that was Benji and he had them removed. **** really cool though about their foundation for the less fortunate, but still HONESTY is key.

Posted by: cara


P.s. I wouldn't be surprised abour Mcartney, I can't stand him - PHONEY and POMPUS

Posted by: cara


Paul McCartney isn't a devout Christian. The BI reads that the rock star is pretty religious. It's one of the Madden brothers. Christian, vegan boys who supposedly denounce alcohol and drugs, yet date girls who abuse drugs.

Posted by: Anonymous


Scott Stapp isn't a vegan, his substance abuse problems are well known and he doesn't deny them and, oh yeah, he's married so that leaves him out. So that leaves him out.

Posted by: Anonymous


Paul McCartney

Posted by: Anonymous


Bono

Posted by: Anonymous


Bono is married and isn't a vegetarian. It's not Paul McCartney. He's a little too old for that sh*t. When I think of compulsive liar, cokehead girlfriend, I think of Ms. Paris Hilton. So my guess is Benji Madden.

Posted by: Anonymous


P.S. The rock star apparently dates plenty of beautiful women. This can't be Paul McCartney since he was married for a long time and following his wife's death hooked up with that psycho.

Posted by: Anonymous


What about Prince? Vegan, devout Jehovah's Witness, well-known list of gorgeous girlfriends and wives. Also has been vocal about abstaining from liquor and drugs. But, here in MN, it's a loosely-kept secret that he OD'd on coke about 10 years ago.

Posted by: Anonymous


Oh good going 10:15! I forgot all about Prince Rogers Nelson. Quite possible that he's the rock star Janet's referring to, but he's so damned private that it's hard to really say.

Posted by: Anonymous


Paul.. ha ha

Posted by: Anonymous


Bono may be Christian and married, but he's a definite player.

Posted by: Anonymous


It's not Bono. The BI says that the person is a devout christian and vegan, Bono doesn't fit that category. Paul McCartney isn't a devout Christian. And he's a pothead. Everybody knows that. No surprise there. I LOVE the Prince guess.

Posted by: Anonymous


If it said POP star I would say Clay Aiken. He is not as clean cut as he likes to appear. He is Known for being a devout Christian, and was a vegan for a few years. Thing is, he has a thing for married ladies (ok, and some men too) and if you look into it will see that he caused the divorce of at least 2 couples close to him by sleeping with the wivws! (Jaymes and Christy) and was the reason his former best friend was dumped by her fiance in 2004 after the guy caught them in bed together. Drug wise, he is known to dabble in coke, but by no means is he as addict.

Posted by: Anonymous


Out of all the guesses here, I'd say Prince is the closest. I can feel it in my sugar walls.

Posted by: Anonymous


Clay broke up a marriage...in bed with the wives? I'm really doubting that

Posted by: Anonymous


Ohhhhh I like the Prince guess. Devout christian: CHECK, vegan: CHECK, claims he abstains from alcohol and drugs: CHECK, has a weakness for pretty women: CHECK. I think we have a winner.

Posted by: Anonymous


LOL Clay Aiken isn't a vegetarian and he's very GAY. I wouldn't classify him as a rock star either!

Posted by: Anonymous


Ugh, I said Clay WAS a vegetarian, and if it was a POP star. Also, if anything Clay is Bisexual because he has had several affairs with married women. Look into Jaymes Foster, the woman he is having a baby with. She was married for 23yrs up till last year. And Clay had a friend Christy whom Clay fooled around with while she was married. She is also now divorced because of it. Trust. It is true.

Posted by: Anonymous


The BI is not about Clay Aiken. Would Prince be labeled a "rock star"? The BI is pointing at someone who seemingly is a goody goody who doesn't dabble with drugs or alcohol. Bono, Paul McCartney, Alice Cooper, the Madden brothers all had past substance abuse problems.

Posted by: Anonymous


BTW most of Prince's ex-girls have had substance abuse issues. It wouldn't surprise me if his current squeeze has a coke problem. You are who you attract.

Posted by: Anonymous


Jehovah's Witness isn't a Christian religion so it aint Prince and since when is Lenny Kravitz Jewish since his Black mother never converted?

Posted by: daniela lepore


Lenny's father is Jewish so Lenny considers himself Jewish. I think Janet is using "christian" loosely. Prince is a really good guess.

Posted by: Anonymous


If it were Clay Aiken, the gossip would not involve a FEMALE ... hello, Gaiken!!

It's Prince.

I can feel it in my raspberry beret.

Posted by: Anonymous


Actually Clay is bisexual. The BI is not about him. AWWW Prince, I didn't know you were such a mess. I guess he's private for a reason.

Posted by: Anonymous


It's not Prince. It's one of the Madden brothers. Vegan, Christian and supposedly free of drugs and alcohol. Read their bios. And both date lying cokeheads Nicole Richie and Paris Hilton. It's not difficult to connect the dots.

Posted by: Anonymous


I like the Prince votes too. Also the blind says he's a pill popper. Prince has had hip surgery and has had chronic pain -- easy to get pills for those things, no matter who you are!

Posted by: Anonymous


It's Joel Madden. Former GF is Hillary Duff. HD was speachless when it surfaced he was dating Nicole because he NR is a cokehead.

Posted by: Malgosia


It could also be Benji Madden since he's dating the other cokehead Paris Hilton.

Posted by: Anonymous


Seriously -- are the Maddens really worth calling rock stars? Also -- if the new girlfriend was a celebrity, wouldn't there be some indication of that in the item?

Posted by: Anonymous


Well the Maddens aren't pop stars. Janet didn't say legendary rock star or influencial rock star. So the Madden brothers could be considered rock stars. Also Janet doesn't have to explain that his girlfriend is a celeb either. Most Blind Items don't work that way.

Posted by: Just a Thought


adam levin

Posted by: slappy


Um Adam Levin isn't Christian nor does he proclaim he's free of drugs and alcohol. Is he even vegan???

Posted by: Anonymous


I agree with Prince

Posted by: Anonymous


ted nugent

Posted by: Anonymous


Ha ha Ted Nugent isn't a vegan!!!!! He's a bonafide hunter who eats his roadkill. Prince is a really good guess.

Posted by: Anonymous


Kid Rock???

Posted by: Anonymous


it's nicole richie and her madden brother.

Posted by: a name by no other name


Kid Rock isn't a vegan nor is he a devout Christian. Prince is a good guess, but he's too under the radar. Do you notice that all of his exes don't even talk about him publicly??? I don't think it's prince. It is Joel Madden and Nicole Richie.

Posted by: Anonymous


Gene Simmons Hes Jewish and a womanizer

Posted by: Kay


STING!!!!!

Posted by: Anonymous


Hmmmm...this is a toss-up? Either Moby or one of the Madden boys fits these clues....The Moby reference with "my weakness", & his is a renowned vegan. But on the other hand, the liar, cokehead current girlfriend fits Paris, & for that matter Nicole perfectly too. Hope it's not Moby, he's far too talented to risk frying his brain...the Madden bros, well, you know......they have hooked up with the skankiest Hollywood fame whores around, so I guess it's rather fitting - meow!!!!

Posted by: discomamma


Andre 3000. I don't know if he'd be classified as a rock star per se, but the rest of the lifestyle description fits.

Posted by: Anonymous


Gene Simmons eats meat & is Jewish -
But Steven Tyler has fallen off the wagon and everyone knows his girlfriend is a coke head
he has dated many a woman and i am not sure about the devout part .. but he is my guess

Posted by: Liz


I don't believe that Paris Hilton is a cokehead. She seems to be doing really good.
And the Madden boys are on tour with Good Charlotte right now, they seem to be functioning very well too. Must be someone else.

Why doesn't Janet just come out and say who she means.Geez.

Posted by: Anonymous


Could be anyone. Most H'wood types have used rec drugs at one time or another. The smart ones do it in their own homes and leave it at that.

Posted by: Anonymous


surprised noone mentioned either Michael Stipe or Anthony Keidis

Posted by: deran


however the one i'm very sure it fits is, the Fall out Boy singer,now married to Ashley Simpson..

Posted by: Anonymous


lenny kravitz has crosses tatooed all over his body. i think he's labeled himself christian...term used loosely.

Posted by: nononono




TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK!



This part is optional!





Latest Whodunit? Items


Remember When?

A 2001 Hollywood Whodunit: This young man comes from Hollywood royalty - both parents are famous and talented. He's gay but his family learned to accept his sexuality. But they'd never approve of his foolish and risky behavior if they knew what he's been up to. He frequents a West Hollywood supermarket popular with gay men and cruises the aisles looking for quickies. Several times a week he visits the store and scores almost every time, using the store's bathroom for his sexual adventures. Employees know what he's up to, but since his family owns stock in the chain, they're afraid to do anything about it.

Do you remember?
CLICK HERE & tell me!

To take a look back through our entire Remember When? collection, CLICK HERE!
More links coming soon!